Without a clear reporting framework, owners are making decisions on incomplete information
I was instructed to review and comment on the individual hotels’ historic performance, the group’s future prospects, and the quality of the management team. It was a straightforward assignment on paper but turned out to be far harder and more laborious than I had expected. Why? Although the portfolio was running profitably, it was doing so without the benefit of proper management reports.
It wasn’t that the owner-manager was incompetent — she clearly wasn’t — or obstructive, it was simply that she’d grown up in and with the family business and learned to operate her hotels without them. Incredibly to me, even the basic concepts of occupancy and ADR made way for just knowing when the hotel was busy or not. She knew what business was on the books over the coming months, how much profit she was making and, crucially in her mind, who her clients were and how to keep them happy. But ask her about market segmentation, rooms profitability or food and beverage margins and she couldn’t answer.
The above is a true story. While it may be an extreme example, there are still plenty of hotels that operate without good management reporting systems. In my experience, the problem is mainly in the independent sector, especially among smaller, owner-operated properties. For context, Hotel News Resource reports that independent room supply still accounts for up to 30% of the U.S. market and as much as 60% in Europe.
The preparation of accounts, whether for internal management use or for statutory and tax compliance, is often outsourced to external accountants who may or may not be hotel specialists. Even when produced in-house, management reporting is not always adequately designed as a proactive hotel management tool. Aggregated revenues, cost groupings that hinder rather than aid operational diagnosis, and a profit (or loss) number do not facilitate understanding of what’s driving the bottom line. As a result, profit can create a misplaced sense of confidence that the business is doing well when it might do better. Equally, a reported loss, in itself, provides no meaningful insight into the underlying cause.
It’s an oft-quoted cliché that hotels are complex businesses. In fact, they are a collection of different business units — a rooms operation; multiple food and beverage outlets possibly; perhaps some leisure with outside membership; a spa; and maybe some paid parking. The key point is not their number, it is that operationally, these are all fundamentally different, each with their own revenue drivers, different cost profiles, unique staffing requirements, etc.
A basic set of accounts will tell an owner whether the business is making a profit or a loss and whether it is generating more revenue than it costs to operate. But it typically gives no insight or clarity into which parts of the business are shoring it up and which ones are dragging it down.
Of course, the key issue is margin. In particular, it’s departmental contribution, the revenue generated by a department minus the direct costs of operating it, before shared property-wide expenses. What contributes to departmental margin and what erodes it?
Take rooms for example. Basic accounts might show rooms revenue as stable, or even increasing relative to last year, but they don’t differentiate between different sources of bookings or break out rooms-specific costs. Commissions, usually hidden within a broader cost category, may be creeping up as a result of a shift in distribution channels, specifically affecting rooms and therefore overall profitability without it being obvious. Without that insight, a poor decision might easily be taken to cut back in-room amenities or reduce linen changes.
Food and beverage presents entirely different challenges. Profit might be down and that, in itself, may or may not be apparent. And the reasons could be manifold: increased supplier prices, poor portion control, excess wastage, to name but a few. Without the granular information to monitor each of these, it’s impossible to determine the cause, again potentially leading to management decisions which fail to address the actual root of the problem.
Enter USALI, or the Uniform System of Accounts for the Lodging Industry: 100 years old and now in its 12th Edition, it is the de facto reporting standard for the majority of internationally branded hotels. But why? Because in simple terms, it is designed to help surface exactly these kinds of issues. It does this by setting out a logical framework that organizes revenues and costs by department wherever possible, and also splits them into defined groups and sub-groups based on what drives them.
Independent hotels have — in my experience at least — been slow to adopt the standard. In truth for many, adopting USALI fully would be overkill. But applying the basic principles that underpin it at an individually appropriate level of detail absolutely makes commercial sense for most hotels.
The clear separation and categorization of departmental and property-wide costs based on their main drivers naturally facilitates more accurate, better reporting which helps home in on issues. More accurate, consistent and standardized reporting also makes for easier benchmarking and comparison — be that internally (e.g. year-over-year) or externally with reliable third-party data providers. STR and HotStats both follow USALI-based principles for their own reports.
Structured USALI-based reporting helps all relevant stakeholders better understand the business and what drives it. It guides what questions to ask and helps pinpoint the answers. These in turn guide better strategic decision-making. In the case of my small independent Irish hotel group, restating their accounts in line with USALI allowed me to give the bank the comfort it needed to keep supporting the business.
Patrick Angwin is the founding director of Clanalytix, a boutique London-based hotel advisory firm specializing in asset management, analytics and development advisory.
This column is part of ISHC Global Insights, a partnership between CoStar News and the International Society of Hospitality Consultants.




